Struggling NFL Quarterbacks in 2026: Who's at Risk of Being Benched?
Eighty games into the 2026 NFL season, no starting quarterback has been benched due to poor performance. However, several QBs are facing scrutiny for their struggles, raising questions about their job security. Here’s an analysis of the most at-risk quarterbacks and the factors influencing their futures.
Cam Ward (Tennessee Titans)
Cam Ward's transition into Brian Daboll's scheme has been disappointing. The second-year quarterback has shown little growth, struggling with accuracy, pocket presence, and reading defenses. His performance ranks among the worst in the league, with a -0.27 expected points added (EPA) per dropback and a 37.2% success rate. Despite the offensive line's issues, Ward has failed to overcome adversity, as evidenced by his poor performance under pressure against Houston. While the Titans need Ward to gain experience, his future remains uncertain. If he doesn’t improve, he may face competition in 2027 or become another failed project in Tennessee.
Kirk Cousins (Las Vegas Raiders)
Kirk Cousins started strong, leading the Raiders to a 3-0 start, but recent losses have raised concerns. Despite physical limitations, Cousins remains effective, ranking in the top 10 in EPA per dropback and success rate. His decline is less about performance and more about the team’s overall struggles. The Raiders may eventually turn to rookie Fernando Mendoza, but this is unlikely to happen unless the losses pile up or Cousins shows significant decline. Cousins’ ability to function at a starter level keeps him in the lineup for now.
Jacoby Brissett (Arizona Cardinals)
Jacoby Brissett has managed the Cardinals' offense but hasn’t shown anything exceptional. His 5.6 yards per attempt and lack of explosive plays highlight the offense’s limitations. While Arizona is likely to continue its rebuild, Brissett’s performance raises questions about his fit in Mike LaFleur’s system. The Cardinals may eventually turn to rookie Carson Beck to evaluate their future at quarterback, especially if the losing streak continues.
Malik Willis (Miami Dolphins)
Malik Willis has struggled, ranking 24th in EPA per dropback and 21st in success rate. However, the Dolphins’ overall offensive issues, including a weak supporting cast, provide some context for his performance. Willis’ mobility hasn’t been fully utilized, and his passing accuracy has been inconsistent. Despite his struggles, Miami is unlikely to bench him, as he serves as a stopgap while the team evaluates its young talent and improves its draft position.
Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers)
Justin Herbert’s performance has been abysmal, ranking near the bottom in EPA per dropback, success rate, and win probability added. His struggles are compounded by a poor offensive line, ineffective running game, and injured receivers. While benching Herbert is unlikely due to his contract, the Chargers may consider changes to the coaching staff, particularly offensive coordinator Mike McDaniel, if the team’s performance doesn’t improve.
Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles)
Jalen Hurts’ season has been marred by injury and inconsistent play. His EPA per dropback and success rate rank below league average. However, his job is secure in the short term, with backup Tanner McKee stepping in during his absence. Hurts’ long-term future in Philadelphia depends on his ability to rebound from his current struggles.
Conclusion
While no quarterback has been benched yet, several are on thin ice. Cam Ward and Jacoby Brissett face the most immediate risk, while Kirk Cousins and Justin Herbert are more likely to remain starters due to their teams’ broader issues. As the season progresses, coaching decisions and team records will play a significant role in determining which quarterbacks stay and which ones go.